Tyler Broderick said:
The only cultural practice that was different was when before we seeded, we lightly verticut the tees and approaches. That makes me think that maybe the seed didn't get down to the soil all the way on the fairways and kind of grew on top of the dormant bermuda. If that is the case maybe it is more susceptible to the colder temperatures?
From what I've seen at neighboring courses, I think you may have answered your own question. With the new trend being minimal prep (to leave something for transition in the spring), I think we sometimes don't get the seed down far enough to protect the crown. Back in the day (20-25 years ago) if you couldn't see the soil, you weren't finished with your prep!
Couple of things I'm thinking of:
Are you 419 or common?
Did the Bermuda come back after the water was back on? September is typically early, but a necessary evil...
If it did, you might lower the heights by a tenth for one or two mowings, then bring them back up... then you'll get your Rye up above the dormant and give you a better look from the tee.
Lastly... this has been the weirdest overseed season I've seen in a number of years.